Free GrandTotal1/7/2024 ![]() ![]() The rest of the judges scores were 'closer' for that matter - all from 7 to 8.50 for the components and from 116 to 126 points for the overall free skate score. And it's not like any other judge in the panel was close with American judge opinion about Gubanova skate and his CO score especially. With less skaters involved or better to say with less 'zamboni breaks', as statistically, this kind of discrepancy should'n be achievable that easy. No, Gubanova is not the first and not the last skater who has this happening to her (and for sure it does not only happen if your name ends with ova and you train in Russia).Ĭlick to expand.I was talking about a Grand Prix competition (with max 12 skaters involved, or only two groups of skaters, without break for the judges for the ice resurfacing), not about a competition of 24 skaters or more. Especially the composition score seems a mess because people don't know how to judge this especially now with the new component number and the integration of transitions. These are just some random examples from 2 competitions I just looked up. Really? Have they ever seen Mikutina skate in their life?Īt recent Nebelhorn: Livia Kaiser composition 4.00-7.00. Mikutina got 5.50 for skating skills from the Dutch judge. Schiza's composition score ranged from 5.75 to 8. Nicole Schott was 1st in presentation according to the Dutch judge, 12th according to the Slovenian one. Malinin was 5th in composition according to the Korean and Turkish judge, 18th according to the Austrian one. ![]() Junhwan Cha was 10th in presentation at last year's worlds according to the Turkish judge, 1st according to US and Korean judge. ![]() We can absolutely talk about Gubanova not being judged correctly by certain judges -however if that's the biggest discrepancy you have ever seen you may not have looked at too many scores closely because I have seen many of those unfortunately. ![]()
0 Comments
Leave a Reply.AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. ArchivesCategories |